Letters: May 2 & 4, 1895 - The letter that sparked a public debate from "A Gentleman from Kingston" & response from an overseer of Rose Hall, John W. Broderick May 8 & 10, 1895 - C. Plummer re. overseer's letter and overseer's response May 15, 1895 - Four Letters corroborating and rebutting overseer's story including letters by T.S.C., Hon. Richmond Hill, C Plummers and JW Gruber May 28, 1895 - Second letter from "A Gentleman from Kingston", author of initial letter that sparked the debate Jun 17, 1895 - Letter to the Editor from G. M MCLAUGHLIN attempting to set the record straight Jul 23, 1895 - Letter from Leslie Alexander (employee of the Island's Record Office) Jul 31, 1895 - Third letter from "A Gentleman from Kingston" whose initial letter sparked the public debate Aug 2, 1895 - Second Letter from Leslie Alexander, an employee of the Record's Office